As Ghana’s countdown to the World Cup gathers pace, the debate over experience versus form has once again taken center stage—and few names ignite that discussion like Andre Ayew.

Ghanaian football analyst Charles has weighed in, urging Black Stars head coach Otto Addo to approach Ayew’s potential inclusion with careful consideration. Speaking on Angel TV, Charles made it clear that while the veteran forward’s legacy with the national team is undeniable, a place in the World Cup squad must be earned, not gifted.

According to the analyst, Ayew’s wealth of experience, leadership qualities, and deep understanding of international football remain valuable assets. Over the years, the former captain has been a guiding presence for Ghana, influencing games not just through performance but through mentality and leadership in the dressing room.

“Andre Ayew has been a critical figure for Ghana over the years, both on and off the pitch,” Charles explained. “He brings maturity, guidance, and an understanding of international football that younger players can learn from. But the World Cup cannot be about past achievements alone—current performance is essential.”

For Charles, merit must be the guiding principle. He stressed that Ayew’s selection should depend entirely on how he performs at his new club, arguing that this approach promotes fairness, unity, and healthy competition within the Black Stars squad.

“If Andre performs exceptionally well at his new club, then Otto Addo should consider him,” he added. “The World Cup is a stage for players at their peak, and Ayew is capable of delivering—if he reaches top form.”

Beyond individual selection, Charles highlighted the importance of balance. While Ghana’s emerging talents bring speed, hunger, and energy, seasoned figures like Ayew offer calmness and clarity in high-pressure moments—qualities that often decide matches at major tournaments.

Still, the analyst warned against sentimentality. He emphasized that Ayew’s return should not be symbolic or nostalgic, but the result of consistent, high-level performances. The World Cup, he noted, is unforgiving, and only players in optimal condition should be trusted on such a stage.

“We must avoid nostalgia-driven selections,” Charles concluded. “Andre’s quality is unquestionable, but he has to prove himself this season to earn that place.”

His comments have sparked lively debate among Ghanaian football fans. Some believe Ayew’s proven record in major tournaments makes him indispensable when the stakes are highest. Others echo Charles’ stance, insisting that form, fitness, and performance must outweigh reputation.

With the World Cup drawing closer, every decision by Otto Addo will be closely examined. And for Andre Ayew, the message is clear: the door is open—but only performance will decide whether he walks through it.